Now i have done quite a lot of study on which one is better and i have picked the Dividend option. Let me argue it out in the next few paragraphs. This is valid only for equity mutual fund and not logical for the income/debt mutual fund.
Let us assume that i decide to invest Rs 5000 on a NFO or an existing mutual fund and assuming the face value or the present value is 100 i get 50 shares of mutual fund. The dividend scheme gave 50% dividend in the first year itself as the market was really good. Now i decide to sell after 2 years and take out 3500 due to some unforeseen scenario (Effectively delaying is non-negotiable) and that the market had tanked and my mutual fund return on this day went down by 25% from the face value at which i bought. So let us see how the three different scheme perform:
- Option 1 (Growth): End of two year i get 75 per share or my investment is Rs 3500/-. I sell all my shares and get back my 3500.
- Option 2 (Dividend): After the dividend my MF value is 50/- (as 50 was given in first year) in dividend option. I have 2500 as dividend tax free. It gets 5% interest from bank (after catering to Income Tax) and after one year it is 2500+125= 2625/-. On second year, as in growth option my value tanks by 25%. SO it is now Rs 37.5. I have already 2625 in bank. so i need the to sell 24 shares to get the remaining 900/-. So i am still left with 975 rupees (in my mutual fund even after meeting my exigencies) which again can go up.
- Option 3 (Dividend reinvestment option): The 50 i got in dividend is reinvested at 50 per share. so i get additional 48 shares (taking care of entry load of 2.25%). so in total i have 98 shares @ Rs 50 in year 1. Now in Year 2 when i sell as i mentioned earlier market tanked by 25% and share value is 37.5. so to get 3500 for my exigencies i sell 94 shares which is worth 3525/-. So now i have 4 shares with value 150. So advantage over option 1 is i made 175 (25 in cash and 150 worth stock which can go up in future)
So till rules of the game change, i will bet on dividend option for Equity.